Best Pizza Places In Sheffield To Add To Your List

Table of Contents

Pizza is life is a motto that we stand by here at Prestige Living.

If you love pizza and live at Straits Manor, or you are moving to Sheffield soon, we’re here to help.

There has been a growth in popularity of pizza in recent years, especially in the form of the Neapolitan style, which is why you’ll see a few of that style of pizzeria in our list.

There’s good reason for this, as the quality is outstanding, the ingredients fresh, and the service in each impeccable.

Luckily for all you students, Sheffield is a hotspot for great pizza.

Below we’ve listed best pizza places in The Steel City to get you salivating, for eating in, taking away, or ordering for delivery to the communal dining room.

No matter if you like a simple marinara, a slice of pepperoni, a veggie delight, or a calzone, we’ve got you covered!

best pizza in sheffield

1. The Porter Pizza Company

Hand-made, wood-fired pizza in the Neapolitan style, The Porter Pizza Company has some of the best pizza that Sheffield has to offer.

The dough is proven for 48-hours, in-house and the wood-fired oven leaves that amazing, charred crust on each pizza.

There are also plenty of student discounts on offer pretty much every day of the week.

So, keep your eyes peeled for those and it’s bound to keep you coming back for more!

The whole ethos at Porter is that it is a place that isn’t just about how good the pizza is but that the people make it what it is.

They want you to come in with a big group of family and friends, to share your pizza and experience.

It is the perfect place to get some food in before a big student night out in Sheffield.

There’s no better way to kickstart your weekend, or any day you want pizza, which is every day of the week for us!



View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Porter Pizza Co. (@porterpizzaco)

Address: 410 Sharrow Vale Rd, Sharrow, Sheffield S11 8ZP

2. Napoli Centro Pizzeria

Napoli Centro is a snug, cosy Italian eatery situated on Glossop Road.

Here you can sit with a glass of wine or beer whilst you eat delicious Neapolitan-style pizza.

There is a really warm welcome from staff at Napoli Centro, which when you combine that with the food on offer certainly helps to make it stand out.

The slow-proofed pizza dough is cooked in the wood-fired oven for around 90 seconds, topped with the freshest of ingredients.

You’re left with that charred crust, the chewy and doughy balance that you’re looking for in this style of pizza, and a craving to go back again and again.

Napoli Centro is as authentic as it gets as far as the best pizza in Sheffield has to offer.


Address: 343 Glossop Rd, Broomhall, Sheffield S10 2HP

3. Proove Pizza

Over in the Broomhill area of Sheffield, Proove is part of the wider buzz of indie bars, cafés, and great little restaurants everywhere you turn.

There’s also some green space for you to relax in too, so why not get a takeaway pizza from Proove and relax outside in the summer?

This is often cited as the most popular and best pizza in Sheffield, one for the afficionado.

They even have a great range of vegan options, lunch deals, and prices that won’t bust your student bank account.

Proove is one of those special places that will become part of your staple, familiar, go-to places when you’ve welcomed Sheffield into your heart, and it has welcomed you as a student.

You’ll want to come here time and again, take pizza back with you to your student apartment, and make it one of your second homes for sure.

A sparkling pizza place to call your own!



View this post on Instagram


A post shared by Proove Pizza (@proovepizza)

Address: 261 Fulwood Rd, Broomhill, Sheffield S10 3BD

4. Rudy’s Pizzeria

You’ll be hard pushed to find better pizza than Rudy’s anywhere in the country, it is that good.

Spreading from Manchester over to Liverpool, Leeds, down to Birmingham, London, and opening a branch in Sheffield in 2022, Rudy’s Pizzeria has an incredible menu of authentic Neapolitan-style pizza.

The delicious pizzas here are baked in the oven for a fast-60 seconds so you get that charred crust and soft middle, In no time at all!

There are so many topping options and specials on rotations it’s hard to pick a favourite.

Plus, there’s even delicious cocktails and Italian desserts which are worth spending your money on too.

We haven’t even told you the best part, it’s only a 3-minute walk from Straits Manor so Rudy’s can become your regular hotspot for you and your friends.


Address: 40-44 Division St, Sheffield City Centre, Sheffield S1 4GF

5. Mama’s & Leonie’s

Mama’s & Leonie’s is an absolute institution in terms of old-fashioned Sheffield restaurant life.

This authentic Italian restaurant on Forfolk Street has been serving up delicious, homecooked Italian food since 1968.

You’ll find generations of Sheffield families have been coming here for decades, for every Christmas, birthday, anniversary and the like.

Alongside the Italian pasta dishes, the light bites, and the simple burger, you’ll find the freshest authentic pizza.

Sit down and enjoy, with the décor and ambience of a past you’ll love to explore, including the parquet floor and framed pictures on the wall like every small Italian bistro you see in the movies.


Address: 111-115 Norfolk St, Sheffield City Centre, Sheffield S1 2JE

All of the above pizzerias and Italian restaurants are within walking distance of your student flat.

Whether you want to dine out for a change, order takeaway or go to collect and bring back home with you, you’ll have a tasty experience.

When pizza is done well, there really is nothing better!

Choose your toppings and let us know your own personal choice of best pizza in Sheffield @straitsmanor_psl.

Read next: Where To Go For Breakfast In Sheffield? The Top 6 Cafes.